Journalist Joris Luyendijk After Interviewing 70+ Investment Bankers: “The problem really is exactly as bad as the ‘banker bashers’ believe”

495 Flares 495 Flares ×
joris luyendijk banking blog

Joris Luyendijk, journalist on the investment banking beat

Joris Luyendijk, a journalist for the Guardian, has been running a banking blog since summer 2011. As part of the project, he’s interviewed over 70 people in the financial sector.

Before he started interviewing financiers, he knew almost nothing about the industry (hence all the interviews, so he could learn firsthand about what was happening). He initially assumed he would discover that the situation wasn’t really as bad as some people made it out to be, but the interviews convinced otherwise. He realized it really is that bad.

Here’s a key quote from Luyendijk as he compares his long-term study of investment banking to his prior long-term study of Muslims. The contrasted journeys here are very telling. He says,

Before studying bankers I spent many years researching Islam and Muslims. I set out with images in my mind of angry bearded men burning American flags, but as the years went by I became more and more optimistic: beyond the frightening rhetoric and sensationalist television footage, ordinary Muslim people go about their day like all other human beings. The problem of radical Islam is smaller and more containable than Islamophobes believe.

With bankers I have experienced an opposite trajectory. I started with the reassuring images in my mind of well-dressed bankers and their lobbyists; surely at some basic level these people knew what they were doing? But after two years I feel myself becoming deeply pessimistic and genuinely terrified. This system is highly dysfunctional, deeply entrenched, and enormously abusive, both to its own workers and the society it operates in. The problem really is exactly as bad as the “banker bashers” believe.

This trajectory mirrors our own on this site. As we continue to research more and more about the financial sector we only become more unsettled. It’s clearer to us than ever that the underlying problems in the finance industry have not been fixed yet, and that unless they’re fixed soon we’ll experience another meltdown of sorts with all that it entails (more job losses, more retirement money gone, more housing problems). This is something the public shouldn’t ignore.

Thankfully, there are solutions to this problem. In fact, Luyendijk’s proposed solutions mirror the exact ones we’ve made on this blog, which gives us hope that people who’ve studied this issue are discovering what to do to fix it.

Luyendijk calls for “smaller banks, … simpler financial products, and much higher capital requirements” and we called for the same things when we say we should break up the banks, reform derivatives, and raise equity levels. These are three relatively simple reforms that would go a long way to making the financial system much safer and ending too big to fail. Plus, each citizen has the power to change banks and support local lenders.

We recommend reading Luyendijk’s interviews, which include gems like an executive coach saying, “Finance is an amoral world, bordering on the immoral,” a former rating agency worker saying, “we don’t seem to have learned from the crisis. It’s back to business as usual,” and a risk consultant saying, “My sense is that a lot of people in finance hate what they do. There’s no passion. But they are trapped by the money.”

495 Flares Google+ 394 Twitter 11 Facebook 89 Reddit 1 Email -- 495 Flares ×

2 comments on “Journalist Joris Luyendijk After Interviewing 70+ Investment Bankers: “The problem really is exactly as bad as the ‘banker bashers’ believe”
  1. Una says:

    I wish you would speak to my husband. He and his partner wrote THREE TIMES in 2004 (?) to the British Chancellor, warning of possible LIBOR malversations, the danger of CDCs, etc. Literally they predicted later events because they were in the business and could see what was going on and where things were heading. No reply. The third letter got one of those “…tralalalala….thank you for your concern… blahblahblah… we have it all in hand…” replies. They obviously didn’t. There’s a hell of a lot you could hear and learn from them…

  2. Rossenbos says:

    I call for interest free money. In other words: close down the Federal Reserve system and private central banks.

Leave a Reply

wall street banks wall street banks wall street banks wall street banks

Join Us:

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

495 Flares Google+ 394 Twitter 11 Facebook 89 Reddit 1 Email -- 495 Flares ×